Physician and Nurse Shortages In Wake of Obamacare
81Medical Shortages
A related HubPages Forum Post asked about the impact that 40% of American physicians closing their practices will have on Obamacare efficacy from 2010, forward. This information originated from Investors.com News and Analysis. However, I saw the beginnings of adjustment back in 1990 and 2010's senior citizens have likely seen related changes before that.
In Central Ohio dozens, quickly becoming hundreds, of physicians have 1) already closed their practices before their retirement ages or 2) refused to see and eliminated from their practices entirely:
- All Medicare and Medicaid patients
- All patients without health and or major medical insurance other than in No. 1 above. This includes "self pay" patients that can afford to pay 100% costs out of pocket.
Top physicians, surgeons, nurses and other medical professionals in Columbus volunteer at a series of free health clinics any one of 4 nights per week and some weekend afternoons. These clinics are seeing longer and longer lines of the waiting ill.
Case In Point
In Ohio, especially Central Ohio, healthcare costs were driven up in the second half of the 20th Century by a prominent family that owned newspapers and other important businesses, along with having many physicians among their members. Health insurance through the workplace became popular after WWII. These particular local physicians began increasing prices, while the insurance companies responded by reducing approved payments. This spread throughout related systems until in 1986, it was general practice for the Bureau of Workers Compensation to routinely allow only 2% disability on a serious-disability claim, while the claimant's personal physician would insist on 98% ot 100%. Thereby, claims for total disability took 15 years to settle, until legislation was passed to require a 10-year time limit.
Now, many people blame insurance companies for high healthcare costs. I think it is the continued struggle for power between physicians and insurance companies, along with those few professionals that have defrauded public and private insurances.
Propaganda
In the 1990s, the physicians mentioned above lobbied against the field of Nurse Practitioner, because it would presumably drain away the business of doctors. Healthcare costs rose further. By the mid-2000s, however, many Nurse Practitioners were in business in Ohio, one of them from the family of physicians that lobbied against the whole field.
In the 21st Century, the field of Nurse Practitioner is joined by Physician Assistant (or Physician's Assistant), both of which are taking up some of the slack - at lower costs - of physicians that are leaving the healthcare business around the country. I look for this trend to continue.
The rise of Alternative Health Care, supported by its own arm of the National Institutes of Health (NIH), is providing additional options for the death of American physicians. On a curious related note, it seems the news is full of the discovery of people practicing medicine without a license (only a misdemeanor in Ohio), some with much success. How many in poor neighborhoods are doing similar, with less success? I think it is becoming part of the Underground Economy.
The nature of healthcare in America may have begun changing to accommodate "Obamacare" many decades before it was conceptualized or proposed.
What are Doctors Doing?
Some retired physicians are going to work for the Veterans Admiinstration in their clinics. Others go to work for pharmaceutical companies or to university research. One group here is still speaking of forming an association for moving patients with controllable high blood pressure to a Lunar Colony. At the same time, there is talk of moving volunteer senior citizens to Mars to comprise the first manned colony, never to return to Earth. Some doctors will go with them, some undoubtedly tired of trying to earn a living on Earth.
Down here, I think we will see more work for Nurse Practitioners, Physician Assistants, Medical Assistants, others on this level, and also for the Allied Medical Field overall. New positions for individuals with less than an MD or DO certification may well be invented and developed, with lower salaries to reduce overall healthcare costs. Fewer doctors will have more NPs and assistant-types under their practice umbrella.
It happened to Dentistry. Our grandparents saw one dentist for all related needs. Today, some practices support several professionals under the supervision of the dentist as he checks their work and handles major cases. I look for the same to occur in the Physician's Office by 2015, along with the emergence of additional free-standing Nurse Practitioner Clinics. The IF in this case is if we can persuade enough people to take up the education and work.
- Top 10 Best Healthcare Careers 2010 - 2020
In 2010, First Lady Michelle Obama created the Lets Move campaign to increase the nutritional usefulness and decrease the obesity of Americas children and youth. Adults must join this campaign to make it...
For Comparison
American Healthcare Job Market on 12/28/2010, incuding about 5 Million jobs:
- Openings for Physicians on Indeed.com and SimplyHired.com : ~ 360,000
- Openings for Nurse Practitioners - 43,000+
- Openings for Physician ('s) Assistants - 60,000
- Openings for Medical Assistants - 146,500+
The first three occupations each have experienced a decrease in job listings in 2010. Medical Assistant has experienced an 18% increase. Future trends will be interesting.
vote upvote downshareprintflag
- Useful (9)
- Funny (1)
- Awesome (2)
- Beautiful (1)
- Interesting
CommentsLoading...
I think it is frightening.
voted up and beautiful! Well written, timely and poignant.
I have worked nursing homes for many years and one nursing home was recruiting doctors from the Philippines to work as nurses because they were making more in America as nurses. There is always a shortage of OT's and PT's as well for many years now. My mom always talked about doctors who even made house calls. New age of pay more, get less.
Hopefully we will soon have some new healthcare educators so that we can enroll some of these students that are being turned away from medical school. If so, we can fill a lot of these positions and also have some very happy graduates that can look forward to a secure future.
Dreadful scenario! Thanks for your insight!
I have worked as in Medical Billing and Collections for many years. A lot of the problems consist of employees who really don't know how to bill and collect, therefore many claims are written off for timely filing. Billing takes time to learn and the laws changes constantly. Physicians only recieves a portion of what is honestly due them and claims were filed probably and followup performed in a timely manner.
In the meantime, there are theives out there who are submitting false claims and stealing millions from the healthcare system.
Patty,
Your insight is presented well. As a former Nurse, I am especially interested in how the public perceives the current and future of healthcare. Thank you for sharing! Voted up!
Your hub is down to earth, truthful information and is an eye opener. Thank you for such an interesting read. In view of all your facts I can't understand, even less now, that America stops the health care being introduced. I know the top, who makes the money, don't want to but the majority who is the man in the street surely want to. Already Hilary Clinton tried to when Chlinton was in power.
In Oklahoma, the doctor/patient ratio is out of sight. Thankfully, there are nurse practitioners here and there who help take up the slack. I agree with your predictions, Patty. I see no other alternative to the constantly rising health care costs.
Patty. how scary it all is. I can see the future of healthcare bill being uncertain. Great information, it really makes you think.
This is scary truth you have portrayed here - and I believe it will worsen before it gets better. We all need to become more familiar with how to take care of our bodies and not just swallow all the 'hype' out there. Believe you are right when you say - fewer doctors, but more 'cheaper practitioners'. Thanks for sharing your many facts!
I grew up VERY poor with no health insurance and, especially as a young adult, the fear of what would happen to me if I got sick. I busted my butt to put myself through medical school. I have been out of school for a dozen years and still have over $150,000 in medical school loans. Half of my salary goes to taxes. Of the half I "keep" a substantial portion goes to malpractice insurance and another big chunk goes to pay my loans. I only have a comfortable lifestyle because I still put in 60 to 80 hour weeks sometimes, to the detriment of my children. I have been working less this last year after having some health problems of my own,so now I just make enough to pay my bills but it's discouraging to give up your youth and sacrifice precious time with your family...holidays, weekends and so on and feel like you don't have much to show for it, especially when there is no end in sight.
I hope that things do change. I'd be happy to work less and get paid less. But, for that to happen, the whole system has to change. You can't pay back 200K+ in loans and tens of thousands of dollars a year in malpractice insurance if you aren't making a decent income, especially if you already pay half in taxes.
Thank you for the article. I agree with TahoeDoc. I am a nurse who went to law school and the legal industry is shot for new practitioners now, so I am trying to make money opening my own business to pay back nearly 150K in student loans. It is very frustrating. I am considering becoming an NP, but I am worried about working too many hours and paying too much in taxes and not having any left over to pay my student loans. Well written article. Going to vote it up!



























ecoggins Level 4 Commenter 17 months ago
This is a fascinating forecast of the medical industry in the coming years. I admit that although you may not have intended it this way, I laughed hysterically when reading the part about doctors talking about opening practices in a Lunar or Martian Colony.